COVID-19 Update: How We Are Serving and Protecting Our Clients

Unique Discrimination Risk-Recent Employment Law Case

April 10, 2014

A recent federal court ruling offers a good reminder of the many unique claims that may be made against employers by their unhappy employees. All Sacramento business owners-from established enterprises to start ups-should be familiar with their risks before trouble arises.

The Situation

Shaw Rahman was employed by Crystal Equation, a staffing company that assigned him to a job with AT&T. Rahman signed more than one document that specifically described his employment as "at-will," and stated his employment could be terminated at any time.

AT&T requested that Rahman travel to Atlanta for a training conference. Rahman protested as he believed travel was outside of his job description, however he did end up going to Atlanta. Several months later, another staff member left AT&T and Rahman's supervisor asked him to take over one of the former staff member's duties, specifically generating security certificates. Rahman stated he was not comfortable completing this work and that it was also outside of his job description. Though his supervisor arranged for training on security certificates, Rahman still refused to complete this specific task. Shortly thereafter, AT&T and Crystal Equation notified Rahman that his position was being eliminated.

Discrimination Claims

Eight months after he was let go, Rahman came forward with allegations against both Crystal Equation and AT&T of unlawful discrimination on the basis of national origin and religion. In his claim, Rahman stated that he was a practicing Muslim from Bangladesh whose original first name was not Shaw, but Mohammed.

Rahman claimed that when he went on the business trip to Atlanta, he had been assigned to room #911 in the hotel. He claimed this room assignment was "intended to humiliate and remind him of the events on September 11, 2001" because of his religion and national origin. Rahman reportedly asked for a different room, however no other rooms were available at that time.

The travel arrangements had been made by his recruiter at Crystal Equation, though no travel documents had stated any room assignment. In fact, there was no indication that the room assignment occurred prior to Rahman's arrival at the hotel. In addition, there was no evidence presented that either employer was aware that Rahman's first name was actually Mohammed, that he was Muslim, or that he was from Bangladesh. For these reasons, the court found that Rahman did not have a valid discrimination claim against either company.

Furthermore, Rahman stated that his termination was also based on discriminatory reasons and that the stated reasons were merely pretextual. However, the court found no evidence of such discrimination, either. In fact, the court found that AT&T and Crystal Equation both had valid reasons to terminate Rahman, based on the facts that he refused to complete certain assigned training and tasks and also due to department downsizing. For these reasons, the court dismissed Rahman's claims in favor of the employers.

Get Help

Not every discrimination claim is valid, and employers should not be held liable for unfounded claims. If you have an employment issue, contact an experienced Sacramento business lawyer for help.

Client Reviews
Kristina Reed handled the legal work of creating a corporation for my photography business in the state of California. She was extremely professional to work with and very prompt in her response times. She explained everything in language I could understand and helped me navigate the process smoothly from start to finish. I was very happy with her services and will definitely return to her for any future needs! Amy W.
As the co-owner of a small business, the process of selling assets was overwhelming. It was great to have [Kristina Reed's] advice throughout every step of a very demanding and hectic process. We were very pleased with [Kristina Reed's] class, focus and approachability. [Kristina Reed] always acted as a valued associate to the company and became a reliable advisor. Furthermore, we thank [Kristina Reed] for [her] calm encouragement when it was most needed would recommend [her] expertise unequivocally. Todd S.
I reached out to Kristina to assist with drafting some contractual real estate paperwork, and was not disappointed. She provided a prompt response and was very helpful in accommodating my request. Her expertise ensured a thorough conclusion. I would gladly recommend Kristina to other individuals needing real estate expertise. Stephen R.
I'm extremely impressed with my experience with Kristina Reed. I used her services to negotiate a commercial lease in Folsom. Our agent had actually recommended a few attorneys to us but we didn't feel comfortable with any of them. I was very impressed with Kristina on our first conversation. The landlord group was one of the hardest you can find to deal with. There were lots of going back and forth but Kristina's knowledge and experience made my life very easy. She was always quick to get back to us whenever we have questions. She pointed out issues on my lease that my previous lawyer totally missed. I recommend Kristina's services to everyone I know. My friend just used Kristina's services for his lease negotiation in Davis and he was very impressed as well. Devin B.